Idaho Gold & Silver

Just went in with a friend to sell some silver. When I was trying to understand how he came to the price he was offering he became very defensive and said I eS asking a lot of questions. Any one with integrity would have happily answered my questions. I seriously doubt his ethics and will not recommend

Super rude. Offered me 53$ for a slabbed 06 w Eagle ms70. Spot is 64$ Told them that's crazy. The owner told her to pass on my other coins. Had some nice stuff. I totally messed up and didn't read the reviews before going here. My fault. Spend your time and money somewhere somewhere else guys. (SERIOUSLY) Also get what your stuff deserve. Other places WILL pay you better.

I had a great experience with Idaho Gold and Silver. Malcolm offered the best price in town for my silver—no hassle, no games. The whole transaction was quick, straightforward, and professional. It’s refreshing to deal with someone who’s honest and easy to work with. I’ll definitely be coming back and recommending them to others.

Cannot explain how amazing the staff is here, the best shop in the valley! I went in and was looking for a silver dollar for my commissioning ceremony for the Army and they pointed me in the right direction and got me exactly what I needed. Thank you so much Idaho Gold and Silver!❤️🇺🇸

1 star review

Really nice folks. They pay you based on the live spot value.

Hi , great service with happy people. honest with what they wanted and did not want . An great evaluation of what we had. Nice place comfortable environment

I’ve visited their store 4x and I’ve never been disappointed. Everyone is fair, professional & polite. I recommend them without hesitation and caution others to be sure they are visiting this location and not others with similar name (those may also be great but I don’t have a personal experience to share).

I have dealt with many gold and silver shops over the years and this is the place I continually return to. The owners are straightforward and fair, with the spread between buy and sell being cut and dry. Even in a rapidly changing market, they find a way to make it fair for their customers. I have seen them advise against a transaction if it was in the best interest of their customer. They let the customer decide, but their honest opinion allows the customer to make an informed decision. They are the best!!

This a little hidden gem or new to me hidden gem lol . Great spot to buy you gold and silver. Bring cash as they charge 3% for cards. I will definitely be doing more business here. If you’re in the market for precious metals defiantly give this place a visit.

Went here to sell some items and the guy sitting behind the desk was very honest and knowledgeable. We left knowing we received the best deal possible. Couldn’t be happier and will be back to sell more items in the near future.

Wow...what a terrible experience. I went in there to sell some BU (brilliant uncirculated) silver peace dollars and was treated so disrespectfully and rudely by the man behind the counter. First thing he said was you don't want to sell these today and when I asked why he said because he could only pay $41 for each one (which is almost 50% of what they sell for). When I said don't you even want to look at them?, he replied he didn't need to because he has so many of them and pointed to a dish of dirty coins which looked nothing like what I had. When I told him we were offered $63 each a few days ago he said he wanted to know where but before he'd let me answer he interrupted me almost immediately (because he obviously didn't want me to announce the other store that pays much more than he does in front of his other customers) and said just go to them then, which I did and where I was paid $22 more PER COIN! He also went on about how he has worked in this business for 45 years and knows what he's doing blah blah blah. Well yes if screwing your customers by thousands of dollars and treating ladies like abusers treat women counts as knowing what your doing, then congratulations are in order. Otherwise, to any potential customers who read this, please visit the other coin shops around town before you take what this store has to offer. You will undoubtedly see a huge difference in prices and where everyone is treated with dignity and respect. The funny thing is if this guy has been doing this as long as he says he has, you would think his rented store in a pitiful strip mall wouldn't be as filthy and disheveled compared to the pristine and classy looks of all the other stores in town. I hope someone teaches this guy some class someday.