Sarasota Rare Coin Gallery

Name: Sarasota Rare Coin Gallery
Address: 640 S Washington Blvd, #100, Sarasota, FL, 34236, US
Telephone: +1 (941) 366-2191
Rating: 5

ID: 1472Store873 mi from youSarasota, FL 34236 +1 (941) 366-2191

As the Tampa Bay area's premier numismatic expert, Sarasota Rare Coin Gallery stands as Florida's trusted destination for serious collectors and investors. This established coin dealer in Sarasota, FL specializes in an extensive range of numismatic treasures, including U.S. Coins, Ancient Coins, World Coins, Paper Money, and Bullion investments. Whether you're seeking Gold Coins, Certified U.S. Coins, or Proof/Mint Sets, their expert team provides comprehensive Buy & Sell services along with professional…

4.5(106 reviews)

Share this Dealer

About Sarasota Rare Coin Gallery

Active ListingLast verified: February 24, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

Official Source →Report a correction

Specialties

U.S. CoinsAncient CoinsBullionEarly Amer. CoppersExonumia(+8)Paper MoneyWorld CoinsAuction ServicesGrading & CertificationGold CoinsAppraisalsBuy & SellProof/Mint SetsCertified U.S. Coins

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review

4.5

★★★★½

8 reviews · 4.5 (98 on Google)

5★

4★

3★

2★

1★

Fermin MirandaGoogle★★★★★Dec 2025

Extreme professionalism and dedication to their trade.

— Fermin Miranda, Dec 2025

Matthew PorterGoogle★★★★★Jan 2026

Absolute top notch service and variety.

— Matthew Porter, Jan 2026

Jim GrimmGoogle★★★★★Jan 2026

5 star review

— Jim Grimm, Jan 2026

steviethebassmanGoogle★★★★★Jun 2025

Ben at Sarasota Numismatics was excellent to work with. They have a nice quality, unique and highly diverse inventory. All the pieces were properly described and the items were packed with great care & fast shipping. Every nuance and inquiry of the transaction was handled very speedily with quick email responses in great detail. Will do business with Sarasota Numismatics again for certain. Many thanks, Steve

— steviethebassman, Jun 2025

View on Google

anthony iannoneGoogle★★★★★Jul 2024

What a wonderful experience walking into the store. They gave everything you could imagine. Bought a beautiful pair of Gold Cufflinks, at a great price. Can’t wait to go back; it’s that great an experience.

— anthony iannone, Jul 2024

View on Google

Ella SpenceGoogle★★★★★Jan 2022

Walking in was breathtaking! The whole shop was filled with good and silver. The guy taking care of us was really friendly and knowing. We scored some cool pieces here. The bathroom is a must see!

— Ella Spence, Jan 2022

View on Google

Sylvia Golden NorrisGoogle★★★★★Dec 2025

Professional from initial call to sale. Clearly explained the process when selling our coins. Spoke with Josh, Brian and Ben, and all 3 were very knowledgeable. Amazing collection of coins. Unique Estate gold jewelry and gems too. A+++ in all categories.

— Sylvia Golden Norris, Dec 2025

View on Google

Trinity VoylesGoogle★★★★★Dec 2025

Love this place lots of cool stuff , knowledgeable people been coming here for years. Dave is extremely abrasive though offered me $300 less for a chain a week after I was quoted a price and then asked “are you doing anything or not” after I told him I was deciding if I wanted to take the deal, interrupted me mid sentence and ignored my questions. HIGHLY recommend Logan he is extremely knowledgeable, friendly , patient great conversationalist. Definitely will come back and do business with just him. Great place some of the employees need a better attitude especially when you are trying to give them business….

— Trinity Voyles, Dec 2025

View on Google