🏪

Coastal Coin Company

Name: Coastal Coin Company
Address: 229 S Osprey Ave, Sarasota, FL, 34236, US
Telephone: +1 (941) 487-8265
Rating: 4.4

ID: 2831Store873 mi from youSarasota, FL 34236 +1 (941) 487-8265

Coastal Coin Company is a family-owned coin dealer in downtown Sarasota, FL, buying and selling U.S. coins, foreign coins, paper money, commemoratives, tokens, and precious metals like gold, silver, and platinum. With over 90 years of combined experience in numismatics and collectibles, they offer free appraisals and expert guidance whether you're looking to sell your collection or learn more about what you have. Visit them in person on South Osprey Avenue or…

4.8(81 reviews)

Share this Dealer

About Coastal Coin Company

Active ListingLast verified: February 26, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

Official Source →Report a correction

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review

4.8

★★★★☆

7 reviews · 4.8 (74 on Google)

5★

4★

3★

2★

1★

danny robbinsGoogle★★★★★Nov 2025

Extremely knowledgeable and professional staff. Been visiting the store for 17+ years.

— danny robbins, Nov 2025

Graham AllenGoogle★★★★★Jan 2026

Great place to trade/sell. Good people

— Graham Allen, Jan 2026

gina lucchettiGoogle★★★★★Feb 2025

These guys are great first they responded online within 2 hrs about a question,then they were patient , understanding as I had brought my husband's coins as he had passed away and I didn't want the coins to waste away, they gave me a very fair price Robert was very kind & I'm sorry I forgot the other guys name, but he was equally kind & funny we had a fun conversation I would recommend this business wholeheartedly! Thank you for your knowledge and your kindness!❤️

— gina lucchetti, Feb 2025

View on Google

Robin OttenbacherGoogle★☆☆☆☆Nov 2025

He wasn't honest on prices for the coins I brought him. Only learned after about thier true value. He really really undervalued to me my coins. Bad man.

— Robin Ottenbacher, Nov 2025

View on Google

Diana HansenGoogle★★★★★Sep 2025

Great people Skyy and Robert were awesome. Really enjoyed speaking with them. I would highly recommend them to anyone very fair on pricing and very knowledgeable. Thank you again ,Diana Winn

— Diana Hansen, Sep 2025

View on Google

Shayla DeanGoogle★★★★★Jan 2026

Always a positive experience. We drive from 90 mins away to visit their shop. Worth the drive. Friendly staff and fair prices. Excellent selection

— Shayla Dean, Jan 2026

View on Google

Todd HuttonGoogle★★★★★Aug 2025

Excellent transaction! My wife and I needed to liquidate a fairly sizable amount of silver and gold coins. Robert was very patient and friendly as we asked questions about our coins. He was very trustworthy and fair in his evaluations. Will definitely use again!

— Todd Hutton, Aug 2025

View on Google