All American Coin has been a trusted Fort Myers coin dealer since 1965, conveniently located at 8841 College Parkway next to the Post Office. The shop buys and sells gold, silver, platinum, and collectible numismatic coins, offering a large selection at competitive internet prices for both collectors and investors. Open Monday through Friday from 9 am to 12 pm, All American Coin provides expert service on precious metals bullion and rare U.S.…Read more
All American Coin has been a trusted Fort Myers coin dealer since 1965, conveniently located at 8841 College Parkway next to the Post Office. The shop buys and sells gold, silver, platinum, and collectible numismatic coins, offering a large selection at competitive internet prices for both collectors and investors. Open Monday through Friday from 9 am to 12 pm, All American Coin provides expert service on precious metals bullion and rare U.S. coins.
Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.
0
Always pays top dollar.— Jim, Jun 2023
5 star review— Anthony P, May 2024
5 star review— Mathaniel “SugarSkullFace” Tuller, May 2025
Seller beware. I went in based on reviews and reputation, but I have no one but myself to blame for not doing my research on the coins I wanted to sell. Shame on me for getting ripped off and thinking I could trust his purchase price as being fair for both of us. I truly believe every small business owner should make a profit for what they do, but DON'T take advantage of someone's lack of knowledge in your area of expertise— Dominick Z, Jul 2021
Over the past 4 - 5 years I have made very many purchases at All American Coin. Each time I was just a walk in and Clayton was very friendly and helpful. If he didn't have an item I wanted in stock.he would get it and have it for my next visit. We discussed my two grandchildren and I was building it for them. So I would purchase two of an item unless I had one then he helped me get the second. I have seen him buying collections, usually very large ones. He has a stock of coins for sale, coin books and other items related to collecting. I suggest a visit to All American Coin if you collect or are thinking of starting. You will not regret your visit.— douglas stewart, Dec 2013
Offering les than 50% of spot price on silver go somewhere else— scott schmidtman, Nov 2025
Really nice and friendly folks. I had to drop off my mail-in ballot and get it postmarked and they were super fast and friendly.— Adam Caruso, Nov 2022
You must be logged in to leave a review.
Log In to Review
