Read the Gemini Evaluation of US Coin Shows
🏪

Castle Rock Coins & Collectibles

ID: 4122 Store 1161 mi from you Castle Rock, CO 80104 +1 (303) 656-0645
4.6 (21 reviews)
Share this Dealer

About Castle Rock Coins & Collectibles

Castle Rock Coins & Collectibles is a locally-owned, veteran-operated coin dealer in downtown Castle Rock specializing in buying and selling coins and numismatic collectibles. Located in the Encore building at 20 Wilcox Street, this dedicated precious metals and collectibles shop welcomes walk-ins during business hours Monday through Friday, 10 am to 4:30 pm, and offers appointments by calling 303-656-0645. Whether you're looking to buy, sell, or have inherited coins and collectibles, their experienced team provides expert service to Castle Rock and the surrounding community.

Imported Listing Last verified: February 27, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

0

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review
4.6
★★★★½
7 reviews · 4.7 (14 on Google)
5
6
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
1
Justine Govea
Justine Govea Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

5 star review

Terra Leone
Terra Leone Google ★☆☆☆☆ 1mo ago

I had an appointment with Dayton and arrived on time. His “store” is a very small nook in the back of a coffee shop. While he was literally holding my spool of Argentium wire, another customer walked in and Dayton immediately began helping him instead, without saying excuse me or acknowledging me at all. Given the tight space, it was especially awkward and felt very rude and unprofessional. His appearance was unkempt, and the handling of my materials did not inspire confidence. He attempted to measure the Argentium wire using a plastic tub and did not tare the scale, which is concerning when dealing with precious metals. Ultimately, paying a 10% fee on materials worth thousands of dollars simply for him to act as a courier between me and the refiner does not make sense, especially since I have an EIN and have since been approved to work directly with the refiner myself. Overall, it was an unpleasant and disappointing interaction, and I would not return. ***Edit I’m disappointed that instead of addressing my concerns directly, you chose to comment on my outfit and bring the owner of Coff33 into the conversation. Referencing someone connected to my career feels both unnecessary and inappropriate. It comes across as an attempt to deflect and intimidate rather than resolve the issue. For clarity: I was wearing a helmet because I arrived on an EUC. I removed it upon entering. My personal safety is my priority, and that shouldn’t be framed negatively. Regarding the transaction, you stated 10%, not $200. There’s a clear difference. Accuracy matters in business discussions. Also, tare is a basic function when weighing items, understanding how to properly zero a scale is fundamental when precious metals are involved. I want to be clear that I don’t need permission, guidance, or a waiting period to process my experience and leave a review. Customers are entitled to share their experiences on their own timeline. To be fair, I will acknowledge that you gave me the idea to approach a refiner. So ultimately you saved me a significant amount of money. For that, I do appreciate the tip. I hope future interactions with customers stay focused on professionalism and transparency.

Paul Herring
Paul Herring Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

Dayton is a fair and knowledgable guy, quick and easy to work with.

View on Google
gammafilter
gammafilter Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

Dayton has a great shop!

View on Google
Andrew Gassmann
Andrew Gassmann Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

Dayton is extremely knowledgeable, trustworthy, and fair! Had a great experience and conversation, 100% recommend to anyone in the castle rock/douglas county area!

View on Google
Spencer Brent
Spencer Brent Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

Dayton was very helpful and got me exactly what I needed

View on Google
Lynette Kriegwahr
Lynette Kriegwahr Google ★★★★★ 1mo ago

I had a very pleasant experience here! Thank you for your thoughtful and thorough business.

View on Google

Write a Review

You must be logged in to leave a review.

Log In to Review