About Collectible Coins & Jewelry

Collectible Coins & Jewelry is one of the oldest privately owned precious metals dealers in the Bay Area, offering expert evaluations and fair cash value for coins, numismatics, and jewelry in Mill Valley, CA. With an impeccable reputation spanning several decades, this knowledgeable coin dealer specializes in buying and selling collectible items while educating clients on their valuable assets. Even other jewelry stores and coin dealers trust their honest evaluations and dependable service for all precious metal transactions.

Active ListingLast verified: February 27, 2026

Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.

0

Official Source →Report a correction

Reviews & Ratings

Write a Review

4.9

★★★★☆

6 reviews · 4.9 (20 on Google)

5★

6

4★

0

3★

0

2★

0

1★

0

Wanda RoeGoogle★★★★★May 2024

Honest and informative.

— Wanda Roe, May 2024

Christopher KingGoogle★★★★★Oct 2024

Carter is trustworthy and friendly. It is always a pleasure to do business with him.

— Christopher King, Oct 2024

View on Google

Danny ThachGoogle★★★★★Dec 2025

Guns, Knives, Swords, and Explosives are Restriction for Danny T.

— Danny Thach, Dec 2025

View on Google

william connellGoogle★★★★★Feb 2025

Carter is just an honest businessman and a pleasure talking with about gold and the Grateful Dead. It’s a local thing 🙌

— william connell, Feb 2025

View on Google

Keith TsukudaGoogle★★★★★Jan 2021

Carter the owner is great! Very knowledgeable, honest, excellent customer service. I have 4 friends that has recommended him to me. They have known him for over 15 years. Since then I have been recommending him to all my friends. He is super friendly so if you have any question just give him a call or stop by his store.

— Keith Tsukuda, Jan 2021

View on Google

Voluntatem PrometheusGoogle★★★★★Aug 2025

Carter and peg atherton have a long and very close relationship… I guess money really does resolve all discussions… just ask Paul. “Tell me about the rabbits”….

— Voluntatem Prometheus, Aug 2025

View on Google