Located at 3810-I Sullivan St in Madison, Wisconsin, Collector's Destiny is a trusted coin dealer specializing in numismatics and rare coins for collectors of all levels. They buy and sell a wide variety of coins, including U.S. currency, foreign coins, and precious metals, offering fair pricing and expert appraisals. Whether you're expanding your collection or looking to sell valuable coins, Collector's Destiny provides knowledgeable service and quality merchandise.
Located at 3810-I Sullivan St in Madison, Wisconsin, Collector's Destiny is a trusted coin dealer specializing in numismatics and rare coins for collectors of all levels. They buy and sell a wide variety of coins, including U.S. currency, foreign coins, and precious metals, offering fair pricing and expert appraisals. Whether you're expanding your collection or looking to sell valuable coins, Collector's Destiny provides knowledgeable service and quality merchandise.
Imported listing assembled from public business information and numismatic directory sources. Some business details may have changed. Confirm directly with the dealer or claim this profile to update it.
0
5 star review— Daniel Ivey, Nov 2025
Online service had quick communication, item arrived in good condition.— Caleb “Crawdad” T, Dec 2025
5 star review— Matt O'Rourke, Jan 2026
goat shop— Michael Cooper, Jan 2026
My favorite Pokemon card shop by far. Best selection of singles and very transparent and fair prices. Comfortable ambiance and extremely knowledgeable and friendly staff.— Barry Hurewitz, Sep 2025
This shop is awesome, everyone who I've interacted with there have been so friendly and helpful. They've given me great deals on exchanges and have been really generous. Will continue to support this store!— Lucas, Aug 2025
Have gone in to trade and play twice now. Amazing vibes! Just what I want out of my local card shop. Reasonable pricing and trade in credit, awesome for TCGs, board games (they have many for rent), video game area and the most important factor... the owners seem so sweet and create an awesome environment. I highly recommend supporting this new and upcoming shop!— Katherine Johnson, Aug 2024
With a duo of caring and attentive owners, this card shop is always clean and enjoyable. It has a calm atmosphere and prices are extremely reasonable, usually just at or even below market, sometimes they even have stuff right at about MSRP. They make good trades and run a tight ship. Love this place and I always enjoy going.— Sebastian Bortz, Oct 2025
I’m fairly familiar with most of the Pokémon stores in the area, as my son and I enjoy ripping packs and chasing cards together. Nothing against the other businesses in town, but this place has far and away been the best experience we’ve had. Mike was absolutely outstanding. He worked with us to get the most store credit possible with the cards we had for trade in, he was extremely knowledgeable about the store inventory and he didn’t treat us like transactional relationships, but rather actual people who had a passion for collecting. He is literally the primary reason my son and I return to the store. He empathized with our struggle to pull a Phantasmal Flames Charizard and genuinely wished us well in our pursuit of it. Then today… this FINALLY happened!— JM, Jan 2026
You must be logged in to leave a review.
Log In to Review